On Sunday, economist Paul Krugman hit back against GOP claims that public sector employment has increased under Obama, and that such jobs consist mainly of wasteful bureaucrats and somehow count less economically than private sector ones. Back in September it was tea party Senator Rand Paul (R-KY) toeing that line, and this morning it was former Republican gubernatorial candidate Carly Fiorina.

The exchange commenced immediately after Krugman made the point that, had government employment in the current recovery followed the same path it followed under previous recessions in the Bush and Reagan years, unemployment now would be slightly above 6 percent:

CARLY FIORINA: I think it’s important to remember, when we talk about the economy, that a private sector job and a public sector job are not the same things. They’re not equivalent. I’m not saying public sector jobs aren’t important. But a private sector job pays for itself. A private sector job creates other jobs. A public sector job is paid for by taxpayers. […]

PAUL KRUGMAN: But when we say public sector jobs, it is not a bureaucrat in Washington, D.C.

FIORINA: Oh, it is, actually.

KRUGMAN: When we talk about public sector jobs — when we look at the ones that have been lost in large numbers in this — it’s basically school teachers. Don’t think about bureaucrats. It’s school teachers. What we’ve laid off hundreds of thousands of school teachers.

And when we talk about the cuts in public spending that have happened, they are not, you know, some god awful who knows what. It’s actually public investment. It’s largely fixing potholes and repairing bridges.

So, you know, you have this image of these wasteful bureaucrats doing god knows what. What we’ve seen is an incredible drought of basic infrastructure, and laying off hundreds of thousands of school teachers.

FIORINA: It is a fact that virtually every department in every organization in Washington, D.C. has seen its budget increase for the last 40 years. That money is being paid to hire people. The number of people who are — of course there are some teachers…

KRUGMAN: The vast bulk of public sector employees are at the state and local level. They are largely school teachers plus police officers plus firefighters. And your notion that it’s all these bureaucrats — that’s a myth that’s used…

FIORINA: It’s not a myth, it’s a fact. It’s not a myth, it’s a fact. We don’t have enough private escort job creation.

It’s a myth. Public sector jobs at the federal level have actually remained pretty stable over the last forty years. They began and ended the period around approximately 2.8 million, with a bounce to about 3.1 million circa-1990. Public sector jobs at the state and local levels increased significantly over those forty years, peaking at a bit over 19 million total when President Obama entered office. (They’ve fallen since, accounting for the decline in overall public employment.) But nearly all of that growth was in teachers and support staff for the education system, who now total nearly 7 million of those state and local workers.

The other major categories of jobs in state and local public employment are, as Krugman noted, police, firefighters, health care workers, and maintenance workers and drivers for the country’s transportation infrastructure. And the overall population of the country has also been growing, so even though the raw number of state and local workers increased significantly, the ratio of those workers to the overall population did not — 59 per 1000 in 1980 versus 65 per 1000 today.

h/t: Jeff Spross at Think Progress Economy

  1. kaptainkesh reblogged this from seriouslyamerica
  2. mickeymousehasgrownupaclown reblogged this from seriouslyamerica
  3. stateofperplexity reblogged this from seriouslyamerica
  4. ludachrisna reblogged this from seriouslyamerica
  5. seriouslyamerica reblogged this from reagan-was-a-horrible-president
  6. awalt2069 reblogged this from reagan-was-a-horrible-president
  7. remierk reblogged this from truth-has-a-liberal-bias
  8. arcadiasilver reblogged this from truth-has-a-liberal-bias
  9. purplegem reblogged this from commodifiedsouls
  10. warmgrey60 reblogged this from truth-has-a-liberal-bias and added:
    And don’t forget libraries! But the GOP probably doesn’t like those either.
  11. freedomtochooseourownchains reblogged this from truth-has-a-liberal-bias
  12. themadnessexperience reblogged this from truth-has-a-liberal-bias
  13. alls-well-with-the-world reblogged this from truth-has-a-liberal-bias
  14. commodifiedsouls reblogged this from truth-has-a-liberal-bias
  15. truth-has-a-liberal-bias reblogged this from justinspoliticalcorner
  16. fntsycrystal reblogged this from carlfox
  17. silas216 reblogged this from reagan-was-a-horrible-president
  18. hashtagwhatwillittake reblogged this from truth-has-a-liberal-bias
  19. carlfox reblogged this from truth-has-a-liberal-bias
  20. lazy-native reblogged this from truth-has-a-liberal-bias